What if the 2017 Sweet Sixteen games were football matchups?

By Amy Daughters -

What if, for one round only, basketball squads took the night off and subbed in their football team to play for an opportunity to advance to the Elite 8?

Following are the next eight games in this year’s NCAA Men’s bracket – ranked not by how attractive they are on the court, but on the gridiron.

Basketball smasketball…what you’ve really got in this year’s Sweet Sixteen are three FBS/FCS (well…almost) matchups and five legitimate bowl games. #FootballForever

The rankings provided are from ESPN’s Post-signing day Way-Too-Early 2017 Top 25.


All-time series: 0-0

It should come as no surprise that Arizona and Xavier have never squared off in football as the Musketeers disbanded their program in 1973.

Ironically, Xavier’s biggest moment on the gridiron came at the expense of Arizona’s in-state rival, Arizona State. The Sun Devils lost 33-21 to the Musketeers in the 1950 Salad Bowl (in Phoenix). The victory capped off a 10-1 season for Xavier, the best in program history.


All-time series: West Virginia leads 1-0

Gonzaga’s football program took a break for WWII in 1941 and never returned to the field. The final game in program history was a 59-0 loss to Washington State in Spokane on Nov. 22, just days before the Dec. 7th attack on Pearl Harbor.

Two decades before the war made Gonzaga a basketball school, the Mountaineers and Zags clashed on the gridiron – in the postseason no less – in 1922. The game was the San Diego E-W Christmas Classic, a contest West Virginia won 21-13.

The ’22 Zags finished 5-3, including a 77-0 win over Wyoming, it was enough to earn them their only bowl appearance in program history. As for the Mountaineers, they went 10-0-1 that season, the only misstep a 12-12 tie vs. Washington & Lee in Charleston. It marked the first double-digit win season in program history, the next would be 47-years later in 1969.


All-time series: 0-0

The only pairing between active FBS and FCS football squads in the Sweet Sixteen, the Tar Heels and Bulldogs would be a first-ever matchup.

North Carolina dropped a game to an FCS team as recently as its 1999 loss to Furman. Butler hasn’t beaten an FBS team since shutting out Ball State (13-0) 54-years ago in 1963.


All-time series: 0-0

Kansas and Purdue have been fielding football teams since 1890 and 1887 respectively and in all that time they’ve never played one another.

The Jayhawks are 39-118 all-time vs. Big Ten members. The most recent action was in 2015, a 27-14 loss at Rutgers. They haven’t beaten a current member since the 2008 Insight Bowl, a 42-21 win over Minnesota.

The Boilermakers are 9-4 all-time vs. the current membership of the Big 12. They’ve played a member as recently as the 2013 Heart of Dallas Bowl, a 58-14 loss to Oklahoma State. The most recent win was a 37-34 upset victory over (4) Kansas State in the 1998 Alamo Bowl.


All-time series: 0-0

Another potential first-ever football meeting between two big-time schools, UCLA and Kentucky have avoided playing each other for almost 100 years.

The Bruins are 17-15-4 all-time vs. the SEC. They opened up the 2016 season with a 31-24 loss at Texas A&M. They haven’t beaten an SEC member since a 19-15 victory at Tennessee in 2009.

Kentucky has only played a Pac-12 member twice in program history. Both meetings were with Oregon State (1968 and 1976) and both resulted in wins for the Wildcats.


All-time series: Baylor leads 2-1

Baylor and South Carolina haven’t clashed on the gridiron since 1976, a narrow 18-17 win for the Bears in Waco. The Gamecocks only win came the year before, a 24-13 upset of then No. 18 Baylor in Columbia.

The only other meeting between the two was in the 1949 season opener in Waco, a game Baylor won 20-6. That Bear team put together a 6-0 run and were ranked No. 6 coming into a Nov. 5 showdown at Texas. After falling to the Longhorns and then Rice in the finale, Baylor finished 8-2. It was enough to earn them mention at No. 20 in the final AP, their first postseason ranking in program history.


All-time series: Michigan leads 3-2

Another potential football blockbuster, Oregon and Michigan have clashed five times in history, all in the regular season. The first game dates back to 1948 (a 14-0 Wolverine win) and the most recent was in 2007 (a 39-7 Duck victory). All but one game was played in Ann Arbor.

Two of the three seasons Michigan beat the Ducks it finished with an undefeated record. The first, in 1948 was a 9-0 finish that earned the Wolverines their first-ever No. 1 rank in the final AP poll. The next was a 10-0-1 mark in 1973. The only misstep that year was a 10-10 tie with (1) Ohio State in the finale. That Wolverine squad finished No. 4 in the final AP.


All-time series: 0-0

Though Wisconsin-Florida sounds like a rematch of a BCS bowl game, the two have never met in their long, storied football histories.

The Badgers have won the Big Ten six times since 1990 while the Gators have captured an SEC title seven times over the same time period. If they had played in different conferences, perhaps the ACC or Pac-12, the two would  have a meaningful shared history.

Wisconsin clashed with an SEC team as recently as the 2016 season opener, a 16-14 win over (5) LSU. For Florida, it’s last meeting with the Big Ten dates back to the very last football game it played, on Jan. 2, 2017 – a 30-3 win over (21) Iowa in the Outback Bowl.

Historical statistics courtesy of CFBDataWarehouse.com.

Comment (1)

Sort of surprising at how many big team schools have not matched up…the Purdue-Kansas was the biggest shocker. Now days a lot of football schedules also include games in other sports as part of the deal.